{
  "recordType": "Fabivo internal comparison on five hard cut lists; not an independent evaluation. The rival numbers are our structured observation: no screenshots, DOM or interface tables.",
  "observedDateUtc": "2026-11-15",
  "selection": "The five lists were fixed before any result of the rival was seen.",
  "stock": {
    "csv": "/showcase/comparison/challenges-stock.csv",
    "width": 2440,
    "height": 1220,
    "quantity": 40
  },
  "common": {
    "unit": "mm",
    "edgeTrim": 0,
    "rotation90Allowed": true,
    "grainConstrained": false
  },
  "fabivo": {
    "method": "runOptimization from src/ui/runOptimization.ts, as the app runs it",
    "priority": "balanced (Fewest sheets)",
    "firstCuts": "any",
    "runTime": "Local computation; device-dependent, not a controlled speed benchmark",
    "measuredDateUtc": "2026-11-15",
    "developmentUse": "These inputs were used to improve the optimizer. Fabivo was measured again after the changes; the rival was not rerun.",
    "regenerateCommand": "COMPARISON_WRITE=1 npx vitest run scripts/seo/comparison.test.ts"
  },
  "cutlistOptimizer": {
    "officialUrl": "https://www.cutlistoptimizer.com/",
    "observedVersion": "1.12.1",
    "accountUsed": false,
    "paymentMade": false,
    "optimizedFor": "Least wasted area",
    "cutOrientation": "Optimal",
    "calculationsRequested": 5,
    "intermediateResultAccepted": false,
    "runTime": "about 70 s per list, on its server",
    "observedAtUtc": "2026-11-15T04:42Z to 04:55Z"
  },
  "cases": [
    {
      "id": "challenge-1-kitchen",
      "name": "Kitchen run with tall and base units",
      "partsCsv": "/showcase/comparison/challenge-1-kitchen-parts.csv",
      "kerf": 3,
      "knownMinimumSheets": null,
      "fabivo": {
        "pieces": 94,
        "unfitted": 0,
        "sheets": 9,
        "cuts": 134,
        "cutLengthMm": 105752,
        "usedPerSheetPercent": [
          91,
          90,
          94,
          94,
          94,
          90,
          91,
          95,
          91
        ],
        "largestOffcutMm": [
          122,
          677
        ]
      },
      "cutlistOptimizer": {
        "sheets": 10,
        "usedPercent": 83,
        "cuts": 137,
        "cutLengthMm": 107088,
        "panelsPlaced": 94
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "challenge-2-puzzle",
      "name": "Four sheets cut into 40 pieces with edge-to-edge cuts and no kerf: a perfect fit exists",
      "partsCsv": "/showcase/comparison/challenge-2-puzzle-parts.csv",
      "kerf": 0,
      "knownMinimumSheets": 4,
      "fabivo": {
        "pieces": 40,
        "unfitted": 0,
        "sheets": 4,
        "cuts": 36,
        "cutLengthMm": 30058,
        "usedPerSheetPercent": [
          100,
          100,
          100,
          100
        ],
        "largestOffcutMm": [
          0,
          0
        ]
      },
      "cutlistOptimizer": {
        "sheets": 5,
        "usedPercent": 80,
        "cuts": 71,
        "cutLengthMm": 54912,
        "panelsPlaced": 40
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "challenge-3-mixed",
      "name": "Random sizes from 80 to 1200 mm",
      "partsCsv": "/showcase/comparison/challenge-3-mixed-parts.csv",
      "kerf": 3,
      "knownMinimumSheets": null,
      "fabivo": {
        "pieces": 46,
        "unfitted": 0,
        "sheets": 8,
        "cuts": 85,
        "cutLengthMm": 73125,
        "usedPerSheetPercent": [
          95,
          93,
          90,
          89,
          91,
          96,
          80,
          73
        ],
        "largestOffcutMm": [
          1184,
          495
        ]
      },
      "cutlistOptimizer": {
        "sheets": 9,
        "usedPercent": 78,
        "cuts": 77,
        "cutLengthMm": 81944,
        "panelsPlaced": 46
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "challenge-4-small",
      "name": "Many small parts from 60 to 700 mm",
      "partsCsv": "/showcase/comparison/challenge-4-small-parts.csv",
      "kerf": 3,
      "knownMinimumSheets": null,
      "fabivo": {
        "pieces": 165,
        "unfitted": 0,
        "sheets": 10,
        "cuts": 278,
        "cutLengthMm": 165577,
        "usedPerSheetPercent": [
          98,
          97,
          96,
          97,
          96,
          94,
          94,
          95,
          90,
          22
        ],
        "largestOffcutMm": [
          1869,
          802
        ]
      },
      "cutlistOptimizer": {
        "sheets": 10,
        "usedPercent": 88,
        "cuts": 257,
        "cutLengthMm": 183904,
        "panelsPlaced": 165,
        "usedPerSheetPercent": [
          98,
          94,
          94,
          92,
          91,
          91,
          90,
          84,
          81,
          64
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "challenge-5-kitchen",
      "name": "Second kitchen run",
      "partsCsv": "/showcase/comparison/challenge-5-kitchen-parts.csv",
      "kerf": 3,
      "knownMinimumSheets": null,
      "fabivo": {
        "pieces": 100,
        "unfitted": 0,
        "sheets": 11,
        "cuts": 146,
        "cutLengthMm": 125152,
        "usedPerSheetPercent": [
          91,
          91,
          89,
          87,
          88,
          85,
          88,
          92,
          97,
          93,
          95
        ],
        "largestOffcutMm": [
          2440,
          148
        ]
      },
      "cutlistOptimizer": {
        "sheets": 12,
        "usedPercent": 83,
        "cuts": 149,
        "cutLengthMm": 126981,
        "panelsPlaced": 100,
        "usedPerSheetPercent": [
          95,
          94,
          92,
          90,
          89,
          89,
          87,
          85,
          84,
          79,
          62,
          49
        ]
      }
    }
  ],
  "limits": [
    "Five lists, one sheet size, run by Fabivo. No broad ranking.",
    "Free settings of the rival only: no edge trim, no paid priority or cut orientation.",
    "No grain, edge banding, mixed stock or materials.",
    "Cuts and cut lengths are as each product reports them, without proof of equal counting rules.",
    "Run times are not a benchmark: one runs in the browser, the other on a server."
  ]
}
